Sonia Exelby was manipulated for years online by a man who called himself “Alpha Sadist,” a court has heard. A vulnerable British woman was reportedly preyed upon by a twisted predator she met on a fetish website, before he allegedly murdered her “for his own sadistic pleasure,” a US court was told. During the Florida trial of Dwain Hall, 54, whose online username was Alpha Sadist, jurors heard that he had acted as the “executioner” of Sonia Exelby and had demanded $4,000 from her in exchange for killing her when she travelled to the US last October.
Proceedings in Ocala heard that the 32-year-old, from Southsea in Portsmouth, had wanted to die. The jury was told that Ms Exelby had a troubled childhood and had struggled with mental illness throughout her life, including self-harm and attempted suicide. She was reported missing from her home on October 12 last year, by which time police had established that she had already left the country.
Her body was later found by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on October 17. Hall, who is from Ocala, was arrested on charges of first-degree murder and kidnapping. He had already been detained over the alleged fraudulent use of Ms Exelby’s credit cards.
Opening the trial, assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told the jury that Ms Exelby was “brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself Alpha Sadist, a man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women.” “That man is the defendant Dwain Hall,” she said. “Sonia Exelby was a beautiful, kind woman who was deeply loved by everyone who knew her. But sadly, she suffered from mental illness for most of her life.
“She met the defendant online and he manipulated her for years. He targeted her because of her mental illness and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure. “And when he finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body.” Addressing Ms Exelby’s mental health, Ms Berndt said she had been trying to find “some substitute” for self-harm, “some outlet that would make her feel alive and feel something again.” The prosecutor added: “Unfortunately, she found another outlet… about two years before her death, and ultimately that outlet would lead to her murder.” The court heard that Ms Exelby had been communicating with “many different men” through a fetish website that has since been shut down.
Ms Berndt said: “She was trying to find somebody that would kill her. Her mental health was declining. She wanted to die, and she knew that she couldn’t do it herself.
“And unfortunately, there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill Sonia in the most torturous and vile ways possible, and they would send her messages and describe to her how they would kill her.” She added: “Even though there were many men competing for this job, one man won out. “One man would manipulate and groom Sonia until he won the job of being her executioner. That person was the defendant Dwain Hall.” Hall’s biography on his Alpha Sadist profile said he would “love to find a domestic pain slut for complete control.” He and Ms Exelby later communicated through an encrypted app that automatically deleted messages.
The court heard that an earlier attempt by the pair to meet, and for Hall to kill her in March 2025, had failed. Ms Berndt said: “After that fell through, the defendant realised, ‘Hey, not only can I kill her, but I might as well get some money from it as well.’ And he told her that she had to bring $4,000 with her when she actually came here for him to kill her.” A new meeting was arranged for October 2025, and Ms Exelby booked a plane ticket and a rental property near Ocala. Before her arrival, a receipt reportedly showed that Hall had bought a shovel and rope.
Police traced him through an attempted credit card use by the roadside assistance company he owned. When officers questioned him, Hall allegedly lied for four hours and invented “a wild, nonsensical story” before later recanting and admitting he knew Sonia and had been communicating with her for years, the court heard. He said he had sex with her and that he hit and choked her during it.
Ms Berndt said: “Ultimately, he says he helped Sonia get what she wanted.” A search of Hall’s home allegedly uncovered the shovel with Ms Exelby’s blood on it. Investigators also recovered a knife from a package Hall had sent to a friend in Ohio. Ms Exelby’s semi-naked body was found on Friday, October 17, buried in woodland where Hall’s phone had been located for an hour and 20 minutes on the morning of October 12.
She had been stabbed four times in the left side, with a post-mortem examination finding the wounds were between four and seven inches deep and had “all hit vital structures.” The court also heard that Hall tried “to erase every trace of Sonia on his phone,” but a forensic examination recovered nude images of her, along with “numerous images of women being raped, tortured and murdered.” Ms Berndt said this was evidence that the reason Hall beat, stabbed and murdered Sonia was “for his own sadistic pleasure.” Hall’s defence lawyer told the jury: “We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall did not murder.”